Interested in property management services? Find out how we help Los Angeles owners with their rental properties. >

8 Effective Tenant Screening Tips for Landlords

Home - 8 Effective Tenant Screening Tips for Landlords

As a landlord, one of the most crucial aspects of managing your rental property is selecting the right tenants. Effective tenant screening is essential to ensure that your property is well-maintained, rent is paid on time, and you avoid potential legal issues. At EGL Properties, we understand the importance of thorough tenant screening and are here to provide you with valuable tips to help you make informed decisions and secure reliable tenants for your rental properties.

1. Establish Clear Tenant Criteria

Before you begin the screening process, it’s essential to establish clear tenant criteria. Determine what qualities are most important to you, such as income level, credit score, rental history, and employment stability. These criteria will serve as a baseline for evaluating prospective tenants and ensure consistency and fairness in your screening process.


A common criteria might include:

  • Monthly income that is at least three times the rent.
  • A credit score of 650 or higher.
  • No history of evictions or significant criminal records.

2. Use a Comprehensive Rental Application

A comprehensive rental application is a vital tool in the tenant screening process. It should collect detailed information about the applicant, including personal information, employment history, income, rental history, and references. Ensure that your rental application complies with all local, state, and federal laws regarding discrimination and privacy.


Your rental application might include sections for:

  • Personal details (name, contact information, social security number).
  • Employment history and current income.
  • Rental history, including previous landlords’ contact information.
  • References (both personal and professional).
  • Authorization for background and credit checks.

3. Conduct Thorough Background Checks

Conducting thorough background checks is essential to verify the information provided by the applicant and uncover any potential red flags. Background checks should include credit reports, criminal history, and eviction history. Many property management companies, like EGL Properties, offer services to conduct these checks efficiently and accurately.

Credit Check:

A credit check provides insight into the applicant’s financial responsibility and reliability. Look for a history of timely payments, low debt-to-income ratio, and overall creditworthiness.

Criminal Background Check:

A criminal background check helps ensure the safety and security of your property and other tenants. Pay attention to serious offenses, but be aware of local laws regarding how criminal records can be used in the screening process.

Eviction History:

Check for past evictions as they can indicate potential issues with rent payments or problematic behavior.

4. Verify Employment and Income

Verifying an applicant’s employment and income is crucial to ensure they can afford the rent. Request recent pay stubs, tax returns, or a letter from their employer confirming their income and employment status. Consistent and stable income is a strong indicator of the tenant’s ability to pay rent on time.


  • Require at least three recent pay stubs.
  • Contact the employer directly to verify employment status and income.
  • For self-employed applicants, request recent tax returns or bank statements.

5. Check Rental History and References

Contacting previous landlords and checking rental history provides valuable insights into the applicant’s behavior as a tenant. Ask about their payment history, how they maintained the property, and if they followed the lease terms. Additionally, contact personal and professional references to gain a broader understanding of the applicant’s character and reliability.

Questions to Ask Previous Landlords:

  • Did the tenant pay rent on time?
  • Did they maintain the property well?
  • Were there any complaints or issues?
  • Would you rent to them again?

6. Set Clear Lease Terms and Expectations

Once you have selected a tenant, it’s essential to set clear lease terms and expectations. Ensure the lease agreement is comprehensive and covers all aspects of the tenancy, including rent amount, due dates, security deposit, maintenance responsibilities, and rules for the property. Clear communication and documentation help prevent misunderstandings and disputes down the line.

Key Lease Terms to Include:

  • Rent amount and payment schedule.
  • Security deposit details.
  • Maintenance and repair responsibilities.
  • Rules regarding pets, smoking, and noise.
  • Termination and renewal policies.

7. Use Legal and Fair Screening Practices

It is crucial to adhere to all federal, state, and local laws regarding tenant screening. The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, or disability. Ensure your screening practices are fair, consistent, and compliant with all applicable laws to avoid legal issues and potential fines.


  • Develop a consistent screening process that applies to all applicants.
  • Avoid questions or criteria that could be considered discriminatory.
  • Keep detailed records of your screening process and decisions.

8. Consider Professional Property Management Services

If the tenant screening process seems overwhelming, consider hiring a professional property management company like EGL Properties. We offer comprehensive tenant screening services, including background checks, credit checks, and reference verification. Our expertise and resources can help you find reliable tenants quickly and efficiently, saving you time and reducing the risk of problematic tenancies.

Benefits of Professional Property Management:

  • Access to advanced screening tools and resources.
  • Expertise in legal compliance and fair housing laws.
  • Efficient and thorough screening process.
  • Reduced risk of tenant-related issues and evictions.

Effective tenant screening is a critical component of successful property management. By following these tips, you can increase the likelihood of finding reliable, responsible tenants who will take good care of your property and pay rent on time. At EGL Properties, we are committed to helping landlords navigate the complexities of tenant screening and property management. If you have any questions or need assistance with managing your rental properties, please contact us. Our experienced team is here to support you every step of the way, ensuring your rental experience is smooth and profitable.

By implementing these tenant screening strategies, landlords can protect their investment, maintain a positive rental experience, and foster a successful and sustainable rental business. Don’t leave tenant selection to chance—make informed decisions with thorough screening and professional support from EGL Properties.

Get A Free Rental Analysis

Contact Us